Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

"Arreda (Get Away), Man, Here Comes Woman": Gender and Afro-religiosity in Afro-Brazilian Religious Organizations

Abstract

This research investigates how religious organizations of the African matrix, through the discourse expressed in the songs intended for and chanted to the Pomba-Giras , contest gender stereotypes, enabling the understanding of multiple femininities. In this article, to analyze the corpus , we opted for the methodological theoretical contribution of the French discourse analysis (DA) derived from Pêcheux. We observed that by studying gender in religious organizations, through the figure of the Pomba-Giras , spaces are opened up for new dialogues within the field of organizational studies, besides understanding how some words used in daily life to belittle women can assume other meanings in the songs, contributing to an understanding of the performance of femininity in a non-puritanical way. Based on the reflection proposed by this article, we dare to affirm that the Pomba-Giras is not only a deity, but also one of the numerous modes of gender performance, serving as a lens to understand other forms of resistance and existence of the multiple femininities in various types of organizations and organizational practices. Following Oyěwùmí in proposing an Oxunist analysis of gender and based on the characteristics of the divinity Ọ̀ṣun (Oxum) , we suggest pombagirismo here as an analytical orientation for gender studies.

religious organizations; afro religiosity; gender; Pomba-Gira

Resumo

Esta pesquisa investiga como organizações religiosas de matriz africana, por meio do discurso expresso nos cânticos destinados e entoados às Pomba-Giras1, contestam os estereótipos de gênero, possibilitando a compreensão de múltiplas feminilidades. Neste artigo, para analisar o corpus , optou-se pelo aporte teórico metodológico da análise do discurso (AD) de linha francesa oriunda do pensamento de Pêcheux. Observamos que ao estudar o gênero em organizações religiosas, por meio da figura da Pomba-Gira, abrem-se espaços para novos diálogos dentro do campo dos estudos organizacionais, além de compreender como algumas palavras usadas no cotidiano para menosprezar a mulher podem assumir outros significados nos cânticos, contribuindo para uma compreensão da performance do feminino de uma forma não puritana. A partir da reflexão proposta por este artigo, ousamos afirmar que a Pomba-Gira não é apenas uma divindade, mas também um dos inúmeros modos de performance de gênero, servindo de lente para compreender outras formas de resistência e existência das múltiplas feminilidades em diversos tipos de organizações e práticas organizativas. Seguindo o pensamento de Oyěwùmí ao propor uma análise oxunista sobre gênero e embasados nas características da divindade Ọ̀ṣun (Oxum), sugerimos aqui o pombagirismo como orientação analítica para os estudos de gênero.

organizações religiosas; afrorreligiosidade; gênero, Pomba-Gira

Opening the Gira

♪My St. Anthony, open my turn and close the door

Ô opens the Gira as it opens there Aruanda

Religions practiced in African-based religious organizations are a particularly interesting field for the area of organizational studies to the extent that the universe of deities usually reproduces with skill the lives of humans who are devout to them, evidencing subalternized practices and knowledge that, for a long time, have been – and still are – marginalized by the field of organizations. Keeping these practices outside this field of knowledge is to ignore all the contributions that can emerge from these organizations. Meneses (2012)Meneses, M. P. (2012). Bodies of violence, resistance languages: the complex knowledge sinets in contemporary Mozambique. Critical Journal of Southern Epistemologies, 80, 161-194. doi:10.4000/rccs.701
https://doi.org/10.4000/rccs.701...
argues that the magical dimensions of policies originating in Africa are often overlooked by researchers; however, this "magical" dimension is not marginal, since it is a central dimension of the nature of some leaders and popular identities on the continent.

In the field of organizational studies, religions continue to be marginalized due to the apparent belief that religion is not an appropriate "object" of scientific study for the field of management. Therefore, the study of religion is not attractive to management schools that are considered to be "traditional," nor is it subject to systematic analysis in any case ( Tracey, Phillips, & Lounsbury, 2014Tracey, P., Phillips, N. , & Lounsbury, M. (2014). Taking religion seriously in the study of organizations. Research in the Sociology of Organizations, 41(2), 3-21. doi:10.1108/S0733-558X20140000041009 ). It is important to note that the study of the influence of religion on the theory of organizations and their practices is not well developed and articulated, although religion plays a significant role in individuals' lives, sociability, societies, and nations ( Dyck, 2014)Dyck, B. (2014). God on management: The world's largest religions, the "theological turn," and organization and management theory and practice. Research in the Sociology of Organizations, 41(2), 23-62. doi:10.1108/S0733-558X20140000041010 . The field of management has explored this issue in a light and restricted way, such as in relation to the influence of religion in the workplace ( Dyck, 2014)Dyck, B. (2014). God on management: The world's largest religions, the "theological turn," and organization and management theory and practice. Research in the Sociology of Organizations, 41(2), 23-62. doi:10.1108/S0733-558X20140000041010 . In Brazil, the pioneering study of Vergara and Irigaray (2000)Vergara, S.C, & Irigaray, H. A. R. (2000). The orixás of the administration. Public Administration Journal, 34(2), 1-8. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3sKKH2n
https://bit.ly/3sKKH2n...
makes use of the idea of divinity of the Orixás, using Afro-Brazilian mythology as a metaphor for the study of organizations. Although few studies on organizations come close to understanding religious organizations, it is possible to verify the predominant production of knowledge about a single religion: Christianity. Some knowledge has been subalternized and, consequently, relegated from this area of knowledge, especially when the object of study is knowledge from religious organizations of African origin. This fact is not surprising, since the ontological and epistemological field of the ministry itself has been forged from an assumption in which the central figure of a man prevailed, cis, heterosexual, white, and an employee of industry ( Alvesson & Billing, 2009Alvesson, M., Billing, Y. D. (2009). Understanding gender and organizations. London: Sage. ; Hansen, 2002)Hansen, L.L. (2002). Rethinking the Industrial Relations Tradition from a Gender Perspective: An Invitation to Integration. Employee Relations, 24(2), 190-210. doi:10.1108/01425450210420910
https://doi.org/10.1108/0142545021042091...
.

When talking about subalternized knowledge, one should not be guided only by the idea that this act consists in exposing the thinking of those who, for a long period, have been silenced. One must go further, seeking to develop another grammar, other references, and epistemologies, different from those that are hegemonic and taught to us as "true" or even as the only ones worthy of learning and respect (Pelúcio, 2012). When we take African-based religious organizations as an object, it is possible to verify that some deities are more demonized than others. For example, the Pomba-Gira , due to having a transgressive character, has been seen by the Christian religion as a diabolical deity ( Barros & Bairrão, 2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 . Therefore, "knowing the figure of the Pomba-Gira allows us to understand something of the aspirations and frustrations of large portions of the population, which are very far from a code of ethics and morality based on values of the Western Christian tradition" ( Prandi, 1996, pPrandi, R. (1996). Axé heiress. Sao Paulo, SP: Hucitec. , p. 46). Thus, the Pomba-Giras is a considerable example of a religion that incorporates several human characteristics into the sacred ( Barros & Bairrão, 2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 , especially when these characteristics are tied to gender issues ( Barros & Bairrão, 2015Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 ; Birman, 2005Birman, P. (2005). Sex and trances: sex and gender in Afro-Brazilian cults, a flyover. Feminist Studies, 13(2), 403-414. Doi:10.1590/S0104-026X2005000200014 ; Capone, 2004)Capone, S. (2004). Africa's search for candomblé: tradition and power in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Pallas. . Considering the aforementioned context, the starting question of this article is: how do religious organizations, through the songs destined to the Pomba-Gira , challenge gender stereotypes and how do these songs enable the understanding of what it is to be feminine?

Prandi (1996)Prandi, R. (1996). Axé heiress. Sao Paulo, SP: Hucitec. observes that "in Afro-Brazilian religions, every ceremonial is sung to the sound of atabaques, and almost all also dancing. The songs of Candomblé and the Umbanda chants are instruments of identity of the entities" (p. 144). Barros and Bairrão (2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 also point out that "Afro-Brazilian religions have long been a productive scenario for gender investigations precisely because they are capable of subverting socially rooted gender understandings" (p. 140).

It is important to mention that one of the authors of this research is a member of a religion of African origin. This fact does not make the research impossible, since the field of social demand allows researchers belonging to specific groups to have their activities legitimized and allowed from the sociocultural point of view of the groups of which they are members ( Bruyne, Herman, & Schoutheete, 1977Bruyne, P., Herman, J., Schoutheete, M. (1977). Dynamics of research in social sciences: the poles of methodological practice. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Francisco Alves. ). The researcher's body must also be understood as a political territory that seeks to study some "marginalized" phenomena not as the "Other," but as a way of producing knowledge and, at the same time, breaking with the thoughts of white academic intellectuals who see the world from a Eurocentric perspective ( Grosfoguel, 2006)Grosfoguel, R. (2006). La descolonización de la economía-política y los estudios postcoloniales: transmodernidad, pensamiento fronterizo y colonialidad global. Tabull Rasa, 4(1), 17-48. doi:10.25058/20112742.245
https://doi.org/10.25058/20112742.245...
. Thus, the essential element "is the locus of enunciation, that is, the geopolitical and body-political place of the subject who speaks" ( Grosfoguel, 2008, pGrosfoguel, R. (2008). To decolonize the studies of political economy and postcolonial studies: Transmodernity, frontier thinking and global coloniality. Revista Crítica de Ciências Sociais, 80(1), 115-147. doi:10.4000/rccs.697
https://doi.org/10.4000/rccs.697...
, p. 119). Just as researchers adhere to different world views, they generate a variety of alternative perspectives as they impose different meanings and interpretations on the data ( Astley, 1985)Astley, W.G. (1985). Administrative science as socially constructed truth. Administrative Science Quarterly, 30(4), 497-513. doi:10.2307/2392694 . This article proposes, through ancestral knowledge, to expose a new theoretical and analytical approach on gender within organizational studies, focusing on analyzing the entity called Pomba-Gira .

Here we emphasize the need to approach phenomena from other epistemological and ontological perspectives in and around the organizational one that are not hegemonic, because, according to Teixeira, Oliveira, and Mesquita (2019)Teixeira, J.C., Oliveira, J. S., & Mesquita, J. S. (2019, May). Can intersectionality be Afro-centered in the field of administration? A theoretical essay on the contributions of intersectional theory to the area of administration. Article presented at the National Meeting of Organizational Studies - EnEO, Fortaleza, CE. , in the field of administration, there is a need to expand the attempts, which are still incipient, at drawing close to intersectional theory. For this, it is necessary that these attempts start from Afrocentered thought, in the less limited sense of this concept, and consider issues related to ancestry and cultural belonging.

In this context, this article “disorientates” the knowledge produced in administration, since it detaches itself from the North as its main point of reference ( Lauredo & Oliveira, 2022Lauredo, F., Oliveira, T. (2022). Bewildered administration? a systematic review of the decolonial perspective and studies in organizations. Research, Society and Development, 11 (2), 1-15. doi:10.33448/rsd-v11i2.25378 ). The theory of Afrocentricity is a viable epistemological choice to create these "disorientations," since, according to Asante (2009)Asante, M. K. (2009). Afrocentricity: notes on a disciplinary position. In E. L. Nascimento, Afrocentricity: an innovative epistemological approach (pp. 93-110). São Paulo, SP: Black Seal. , it places both culture and the African people at the center of symbolic and material productions to the detriment of Eurocentrism. It is worth considering that, historically, Eurocentrism has mobilized efforts to subalter and erase African cultural productions, such as their beliefs, knowledge, and ancestral values ( Asante, 2009)Asante, M. K. (2009). Afrocentricity: notes on a disciplinary position. In E. L. Nascimento, Afrocentricity: an innovative epistemological approach (pp. 93-110). São Paulo, SP: Black Seal. , and that racial and ethnic issues are often silenced in the field of organizations ( Teixeira, Oliveira, & Carrieri, 2020Teixeira, J.C., Oliveira, J. S., & Carrieri, A. P. (2020). Why talk about race in Organizational Studies in Brazil? From biological discussion to the political dimension. Revista Perspectivas Contemporâneas, 15(1), p. 46-70. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3wj8GrD
https://bit.ly/3wj8GrD...
).

It should be emphasized that the construction of this article is based on the way the Gira happens (with an opening and closing). The Gira is the moment in which devotees sing in praise of the deities and form a circle to dance, always going to the right; this turn is an ordering manifestation of the religiosity of beings ( Saraceni, 2014Saraceni, R. (2014). Doctrine and theology of a sacred band: the religion of mysteries a hymn of love for life. Sao Paulo, SP: Madras. ). Mediums should dress in their ritualistic clothes and their guides (religious necklaces) and then head to the Gonga (Congá) , where they seek to keep their minds from thoughts that are considered to be profane. They also seek to ask entities and Orixás to help to perform their mediumistic functions ( Trindade, 2017Trindade, D. F. (2017). Umbanda manual for beginners. São Paulo, SP: SATTVA Publishing House. ). In the Gira , there is a separation between the sacred space, where the mediums are, and the public spaces, where the consulters are located ( Trindade, 2017Trindade, D. F. (2017). Umbanda manual for beginners. São Paulo, SP: SATTVA Publishing House. ). Trindade also notes that "during the turn of a yard, several charitable works are practiced, involving traditional consultations with the incorporated entities, passes, cures, etc. " (p. 142).

Starting an epistemological Gira of gender

♪Supreme is a woman in black

Terreiro joy

Your spell has axé♪

It cannot be affirmed that gender is an isolated category belonging to a single sphere of life in society. Gender issues can be understood from an economic, cultural, social, and even religious perspective.

Although Butler has become a great theorist on gender and queer studies, she does not cease to observe these phenomena from the conceptual and theoretical lenses of the North. Oyěwùmí (2017)Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. notes that we must consider that the concept of gender is not timeless and not universal, as is assumed by some scholars and theorists in the field, who do not recognize or consider other social organizations, since they do not look at the dynamics of African communities without using Western lenses. In other words, there are other possible viewpoints from other peoples that are even, in a way, linked to African peoples. In this context, the debate about the universality of gender/sex concepts is presented as a possibility to undertake several analyses about bodies within religious organizations, such as terreiros , especially when considering the ancestral trance and matripotency ( Bernardo, 2005Bernardo, T. (2005). Candomblé and female power. Revista Estudos da Religião, 2(1),1-21. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3NqoJd7
https://bit.ly/3NqoJd7...
). For Oyěwùmí (2017)Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. , colonial incursions led to a delimited conception of bodies: the notion of a male body (male) and a female body (female) came to be understood as an inexorable process.

Olajubu (2003)Olajubu, O. (2003). Women in the Yoruba religious sphere. Albany: State University of New York Press. and Oyěwùmí (2017)Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. observe that in oyó Yorùbá society the conception of body and gender did not exist as a structuring factor before colonization, as it was structured through the seniority of members within families and societies. Oyěwùmí (2017)Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. shows that it is seniority within this society that "classifies" people based on their chronological age. Thus, within the context of yorùbá, it is chronological age that is responsible for the distribution of the prestigious places of society and not the sexual type of a body ( Oyěwùmí, 2017Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. ). The word ẹ̀gbọ́n refers to the older sibling and to the younger sibling of those who speak, regardless of gender: "the principle of seniority is dynamic and fluid" ( Oyěwùmí, 2004, pOyěwùmí, O. (2004). Conceptualizing gender: the Eurocentric foundations of feminist concepts and the challenge of African epistemologies. CODESRIA Gender Series, 1, 1-8. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3MrA8cl
https://bit.ly/3MrA8cl...
, p. 5). Conversing with the previous position, Olajubu (2003)Olajubu, O. (2003). Women in the Yoruba religious sphere. Albany: State University of New York Press. emphasizes that gender is a construction within the life experience of a people and it is embedded in the basis of its philosophy, manifesting in the theoretical and pragmatic levels of its politics, since gender is not independent of other social systems. Thus, it would be erroneous to consider it as a fixed and immutable construct; on the contrary, it is a process. In this same line of thought, Oyěwùmí (2017)Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. breaks with the idea of gender binarism, showing that this category is a creation of the West and brings the concept of bio-logic.

The idea that biology is destiny – or rather, fate is biology – has been a milestone in Western thought for centuries. Whether it's the question of who is in Aristotle's porlls or who is poor in the United States at the end of the 20th century, the notion that difference and hierarchy in society are biologically determined continues to enjoy credibility, even among social scientists who want to explain human society in terms other than genetic ones. In the West, biological explanations seem to be especially privileged in relation to other ways of explaining gender, race, or class differences. ( Oyěwùmí, 2017Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. , p. 27)

The existence of gender construction among the Yorùbás does not translate into notions of oppression and domination of women by men, since it is mediated by the philosophy of complementary gender relations, which is rooted in the cosmic experience of the people. A complementary gender relationship is rooted in all levels of consciousness and religious yorùbá, because male and female principles are crucial to the experience of a quiet social life ( Olajubu, 2003Olajubu, O. (2003). Women in the Yoruba religious sphere. Albany: State University of New York Press. ). Within the state of Oyó, for example, there were not the categories "woman" and "man," but obìnrin and okùnrin , which are not gender categories, but an anatomical distinction that defines male (male) and female (female) bodies.

Oyěwùmí (2011)Oyěwùmí, O. (2011). Decolonizing the Intellectual and the Quotidian: Yorùbá Scholars(hip) and Male Dominance. In o. Oyěwùmí (Org.) , Gender and epistemologies in Africa: gendering traditions, spaces, social institutions, and identities (pp. 9-33). New York: Palgrave Macmillan. doi:10.1057/9780230116276_2
https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230116276_2...
also draws attention to the erroneous conception that male domination is somewhat timeless in Yorùbá societies and to accept its timelessness is to be a gender worker, that is, a case of gender imposition in times and places where there were no socially constructed gender distinctions. The sociocultural experiences of the yorùbás reveal, for example, that women play important roles in all spheres of life, with evidence of this fact in oral traditions and in the myths of the yorùbás ( Olajubu, 2003Olajubu, O. (2003). Women in the Yoruba religious sphere. Albany: State University of New York Press. ). Thus, philosophical and religious conceptions influence the daily life of society and for both there is a need for a balance between the feminine and masculine principles, a notion informed by the assumption that the sexes are interdependent. Therefore, they do not fit with the idea of male domination. Olajubu points out that within Yorùbálândia some women played roles expected of men and vice versa.

The imagery construction of several deities belonging to the religions of African origin in Brazil "permeates, even today, a hegemony of the sex/gender system where myths, in some way, also suffered from the payments perpetrated by colonization" (Passos, 2021, p. 24). That said, the Pomba-Gira emerges as a transgressive figure (divinity) who inhabits the imaginary of Brazilian society, as a woman dressed in red and who exudes danger ( Barros & Bairrão, 2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 . When we look at the Pomba-Gira , deities belonging to the Brazilian afro religious pantheon, as entities that have a gender performance , we allow for a break with several categories, such as "body," "sexuality," and "sex,” thus causing the resignification of gender, through a figure that breaks with pre-established structures ( Souza, 2019)Souza, C. (2019). Let the Dove-Gira work! : at the crossroads, paths and gender mispaths. Florianópolis, SC: Fire: Tribe of the Island. .

Cruz (2007)Cruz, A. M. L. L. (2007). From queen of the yard to the back of evil: a study on gender and ritual. (Doctoral thesis). Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ. observes that the Pomba-Gira reflects the transgression of the images of what is feminine, since it is seen as an eloquent deity, often understood as an entity possessing two genres. An important issue to be observed is that Pomba-Giras incorporate both women and men, disrupting the duality of sex-gender. Simas (2019)Simas, L.A. (2019). The enchanted body of the streets. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Brazilian Civilization. shows that the pulsating energy of the Pomba-Gira presents a liberating character, but one that is never uncontrolled, because it is always controlled by the power of female power, which it manifests as a striking characteristic of the entity: the Pomba-Gira is the owner of its own desires and exposes them through seduction, in a waddling corporeity capable of challenging any normative standard. The next section seeks to provide elucidations about this divinity.

It's time to praise the "street people"

♪Rose Skull I'm singing in her praise,

On the bar of your skirt runs water and bloom stems♪

The Pomba-Giras are examples of how the Afro-Brazilian religions of the Umbanda segment and some traditions of Candomblé can include in their deities human characteristics from a sacred perspective. The Pomba-Giras are entities that are considered to be feminine and transgressive, also known as female Exu, which are complex, contradictory, and ambivalent, as well as their male partner (Exu) ( Barros & Bairrão, 2015Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 ). Meyer (1993)Meyer, M. (1993). Maria Padilha and her entire gang: a lover of a king of castela: the Dove-Gira of umbanda. São Paulo, SP: Two Cities. and Reis (2020) point out some characteristics of Pomba-Giras: erotic, sorceress, seductive, and wise. These characteristics encompass a varied ancestry and culminate in multiple images of a subversive female ( Meyer, 1993)Meyer, M. (1993). Maria Padilha and her entire gang: a lover of a king of castela: the Dove-Gira of umbanda. São Paulo, SP: Two Cities. . Souza adds:

The Pomba-Giras are linked, whether in Afro-religious discourse, or empirical narratives, to the function of supplying demands of consuls and mediums in the sexual sphere. In this way, they break with the phallic organization regarding sexuality, as much as female sexuality articulates itself in a discourse of biology purely in a strategic way. ( Souza, 2019Souza, C. (2019). Let the Dove-Gira work! : at the crossroads, paths and gender mispaths. Florianópolis, SC: Fire: Tribe of the Island. , p. 94)

The Pomba-Giras’ Gira (part of the public cult designed to praise these entities) is permeated by the sound of drums, shrill laughter, cigarette or cigar smoke, bowls full of alcoholic beverages, and lush dresses. Thus, trying to understand the Pomba-Giras through the lens of gender requires indating the categorization of these deities, which seem transcendent to the divisions of "sex" and the imposed and socially constructed gender binarism ( Souza, 2019Souza, C. (2019). Let the Dove-Gira work! : at the crossroads, paths and gender mispaths. Florianópolis, SC: Fire: Tribe of the Island. ). It is worth remembering that the Pomba-Gira entity can manifest in female and male biological bodies, bringing in this manifestation another rupture with gender binarism. In this context, Pomba-Gira is the representation of subversion, disruption, freedom, and sexual order that drives women to break the rules pre-established by society, showing that it is possible to accomplish something outside the concepts and norms that have been introjected over time. That is, they break with the historical continuity of submission and possession that come from time immemorial ( Costa, 2015)Costa, O. S. (2015). The Dove-Gira: mythical resignification of the goddess Lilith (Doctoral thesis). Pontifical Catholic University of Goiás, Goiânia, GO. . Therefore, "the Pomba-Gira raises in women all that is buried by male dominion with the endorsement of society and the Christian religion that is based on biblical precepts" ( Costa, 2015, pCosta, O. S. (2015). The Dove-Gira: mythical resignification of the goddess Lilith (Doctoral thesis). Pontifical Catholic University of Goiás, Goiânia, GO. , p. 111). Another important image passed by the figure of the Pomba-Gira is that of the strong woman able to rebel against oppression and male and patriarchal domination (Mesquita & Oliveira, 2021).

From this perspective, the Pomba-Gira is autonomous, independent, wise, welcoming, daring, subversive, courageous, erotic, free, and able to conquer what she wants, being a power of elaboration of the feminine that diverges from what is seen as traditional and that questions gender inequality ( Birman, 2005Birman, P. (2005). Sex and trances: sex and gender in Afro-Brazilian cults, a flyover. Feminist Studies, 13(2), 403-414. Doi:10.1590/S0104-026X2005000200014 ; Capone, 2004Capone, S. (2004). Africa's search for candomblé: tradition and power in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Pallas. ; Mosque & Olive Tree, 2021). Barros and Bairrão (2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 state that it is "remarkable that prostitution was related to the images and 'life stories' of Pomba-Giras much more for the subversive and sexuality that the prostitute is concerned with than the idea of 'sex professional' (p. 133).

These entities are extremely polysemic and dynamic and not susceptible to descriptive exhaustion (Mesquita & Oliveira, 2021). By reducing them to a single image of prostitutes, a prostitute is committed to the feminine idea rooted in a misogynistic and sexist vision ( Barros & Bairrão, 2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 .

In the daily organization of female subjects, the Pomba-Gira becomes the core of a reorganization of the existing power relations in the affective and social sphere of the members and adherents of this religious organization (Mesquita & Oliveira, 2021), because it presents itself as a protector of those considered to be feminine, allowing them to face the violence and betrayal that comes from men ( Birman, 2005)Birman, P. (2005). Sex and trances: sex and gender in Afro-Brazilian cults, a flyover. Feminist Studies, 13(2), 403-414. Doi:10.1590/S0104-026X2005000200014 . Barros and Bairrão (2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 also affirm that, through the relationship with Pomba-Gira , women see themselves as "agents of their bodies, women begin to reinvent the way they experience sexuality, femininity and what they understand as 'being a woman', so that the sacred also updates more original and less feminine caricatos " (p. 141)."

Each day, with each incorporation, female figures appear or "update" themselves and are capable of continuously offering the most plural possibilities of female experiences (Barros, 2013). Simas (2019)Simas, L.A. (2019). The enchanted body of the streets. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Brazilian Civilization. points out that Pomba-Giras are deities that result from the encounter that exists between the vital power of the crossroads and the performance trajectory of the enchanted, or women who lived on/from the street and who had many loves, in addition to expressing their vital energy, through the sensuality of their bodies, exposed freely and aflowering, in which the idea of sinful body makes no sense. In the terreiros, the terms " Pomba-Gira " and "woman" emerge as correspondents, thus proposing an invitation to create a deep reflection on how these female deities promote women's senses through their performances in rituals (Barros, 2013).

The Gira is discursive: discourse, interdiscourse, discursive memory, and effects of meaning

♪Old devil I'll cut off your horn

I'm going to cut your ass off and

You can eat your tongue I'll make a whip

To hit the back of those who speak ill of me♪

In this article, to analyze the corpus , we opted for the theoretical methodological contribution of French discourse analysis (DA), derived from the thoughts of Pêcheux. Although the guiding thoughts are those of Pêcheux, it is important to highlight that he is not alien to the thoughts of Foucault; on the contrary, there is some resemblance between these thinkers ( Magellan & Kogawa, 2019Magellan, A. S., Kogawa, J. (2019). Discourse analysis thinkers: an introduction. Jundiaí, SP: Paco Editorial. ). Both thinkers highlight "the importance they attributed to the aspects of exteriority of the discourse, the contextual conditions of its emergence, the description of its materiality, the search for discursive regularities and the factors that enabled them" ( Azeredo & Bartho, 2020, pAzeredo, L., Bartho, V. D. (2020). Analysis of the French discourse: Pêcheux and Foucault, two "micheis" in their (dis)meetings. Paths in Applied Linguistics, 23(2), 36-56. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3lkdlmX
https://bit.ly/3lkdlmX...
, pp. 54-55).

To understand what discourse is, it is fundamental to understand what it is not: discourse is not an individual production of the speaker; it is not under the control of the individual who enunciates; it is not timeless or planned ( Pêcheux, 2015Pêcheux, M. (2015). Language, languages, speech. In E.P. Orlandi, Discourse analysis: Michel Pêcheux (pp. 283-294). Campinas, SP: Editors Bridges. ). According to Pêcheux (2014)Pêcheux, M. (2014). Automatic speech analysis (AAD-69). In F. Gadet, T. Hak (Orgs.) , By an automatic discourse analysis: an introduction to the work of Michel Pêcheux (pp. 74-94). Campinas, SP: Unicamp. , for a speech to be pronounced there needs to be conditions of production given. In other words, discourse is a production enunciated through a discursive formation that crosses the enunciating subject and, consequently, it is always dependent on the position that this subject occupies. Thus, the concept of discourse mobilized here is one that understands it as the effects of meanings existing among announcers ( Pêcheux, 1969Pêcheux, M. (1969). Analyse automatique du discours. Paris: Dunod. ), and as the practice of language, the moving word, according to Orlandi (2012)Orlandi, E. P. (2012). Discourse analysis: principles and procedures. Campinas, SP: Bridges. . In this context, Pêcheux maintains that:

. . . a word, an expression or a proposition does not have a meaning that would be "proper" to it, bound to its literalness. On the contrary, its meaning is constituted in each discursive formation, in the relationships that such words, expressions or propositions maintain with other words, expressions and propositions of the same discursive formation. ( Pêcheux, 1988Pêcheux, M. (1988). Semantics and discourse: a critique of the statement of the obvious. Campinas, SP: Unicamp. , p. 160)

What the speaker says, what he announces, promises, or denounces, does not have the same status, depending on the place he occupies; the same statement can be a fearsome weapon or a ridiculous comedy, depending on the speaker's position and what he represents in relation to his speech. A speech can be a direct political act or an empty gesture, to "pay back," which is another form of political action ( Pêcheux, 2014Pêcheux, M. (2014). Automatic speech analysis (AAD-69). In F. Gadet, T. Hak (Orgs.) , By an automatic discourse analysis: an introduction to the work of Michel Pêcheux (pp. 74-94). Campinas, SP: Unicamp. ).

The conditions of production of the discourse are imbricated in a game of images in which the subject is not on the sidelines, but rather inserted into the center, which considers the understanding of the formations regarding his position and the position of the other, in a concrete and historically determined context, thus forming a triad: subject, discourse, and history ( Magellan & Kogawa, 2019Magellan, A. S., Kogawa, J. (2019). Discourse analysis thinkers: an introduction. Jundiaí, SP: Paco Editorial. ). The concept of discourse is dependent on the concept of discursive formation (DF), which is tied to the concept of ideological formation. Ideological formation must be understood as a complex set of representations and attitudes that are not universal or individual but are directly related to the class positions that conflict with each other ( Haroche, Pêcheux, & Henry, 2007Haroche, C., Pêcheux, M., Henry, P. (2007). The semantics and the Saussurian cut: language, language, speech. In R.L. Barons (Org.), Analysis of the course: notes to a history of the concept of discursive formation (pp. 13-31). São Carlos, SP: Pedro & João Editores. ).

These ideological formations are composed of one or more DFs that interconnect, according to which the position of the subject is what gives room for something to be said, because the positions within a discursive formation are interrelated ( Haroche, Pêcheux, & Henry, 2007Haroche, C., Pêcheux, M., Henry, P. (2007). The semantics and the Saussurian cut: language, language, speech. In R.L. Barons (Org.), Analysis of the course: notes to a history of the concept of discursive formation (pp. 13-31). São Carlos, SP: Pedro & João Editores. ) and "the words 'change meaning' as they move from one discursive formation to another" ( Haroche, Pêcheux, & Henry, 2007Haroche, C., Pêcheux, M., Henry, P. (2007). The semantics and the Saussurian cut: language, language, speech. In R.L. Barons (Org.), Analysis of the course: notes to a history of the concept of discursive formation (pp. 13-31). São Carlos, SP: Pedro & João Editores. , p. 56). Pêcheux (1988)Pêcheux, M. (1988). Semantics and discourse: a critique of the statement of the obvious. Campinas, SP: Unicamp. argues that "every discursive formation conceals, through the transparency of meaning that constitutes it, its dependence on the 'whole complex' of the discursive formations, which are intricate in the complex of ideological formations" (p. 162), always being linked to an interdiscourse.

According to Orlandi, "(i)nterdiscourse is a set of formulations made and already forgotten that determine what we say" (2012, p. 33). In order for what we say to make some sense, it must have made sense before. That is, interdiscourse can be understood as the entire dominant complex of the DF, called discursive memory. This discursive memory operates as a semantic support of discourse, in which it functions through the repetition of utterances, forming a discursive regularity that is part of an "already said" ( Pêcheux, 1988)Pêcheux, M. (1988). Semantics and discourse: a critique of the statement of the obvious. Campinas, SP: Unicamp. . Finally, "in historical repetition, there is displacement, drift, transference, a metaphorical effect. And the metaphorical effect is taken over and forgotten, sliding to another place of meaning, a new gesture of interpretation" ( Orlandi, 2016, pOrlandi, E. P. (2016). Discourse under analysis: subject , sense, ideology. Campinas, SP: Bridges. , p. 173).

Pêcheux reports that discourse is far from being configured as a place of human freedom, since "it is always pronounced from given production conditions" (Pêcheux, 2014, p. 77), always being under the aegis of the relations of forces existing between a given political field and the antagonistic elements. Discourse should be seen as inherent to ideology and, as Pêcheux (1988)Pêcheux, M. (1988). Semantics and discourse: a critique of the statement of the obvious. Campinas, SP: Unicamp. says, "there is no discourse without subject and there is no subject without ideology" (p. 64). Since discourse is composed of utterances, it is important to mention that every utterance is linguistically describable and seen as a set of possible points that are adrift, offering room for interpretations ( Pêcheux, 1988)Pêcheux, M. (1988). Semantics and discourse: a critique of the statement of the obvious. Campinas, SP: Unicamp. . As Pêcheux (2014)Pêcheux, M. (2014). Automatic speech analysis (AAD-69). In F. Gadet, T. Hak (Orgs.) , By an automatic discourse analysis: an introduction to the work of Michel Pêcheux (pp. 74-94). Campinas, SP: Unicamp. questions: "What does this text contain?" (p. 63). When seeking the meaning of a text, it is necessary to resort to the act of interpreting. This gesture produced by the analyst makes evident the relationship between history, language, and the functioning of ideology ( Orlandi, 2004)Orlandi, E. P. (2004). Interpretation: authorship , reading and deeds of symbolic work. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Voices. . Thus, DA is concerned with understanding how a symbolic object produces meanings and how it is imbued with significance by and for subjects ( Magellan & Kogawa, 2019)Magellan, A. S., Kogawa, J. (2019). Discourse analysis thinkers: an introduction. Jundiaí, SP: Paco Editorial. .

It's time to "consult" with the Pomba-Giras: analyzing the research corpus

The songs (or points) used in Afro-Brazilian rituals refer to the characteristics of the entities whose purpose is to honor the deities, prepare and maintain the " Gira " (as the ritual is called in which the deities manifest). These songs are passed between generations through oral tradition and their original authors are generally unknown, with them mostly being in the popular domain. Some have been recorded by popular music performers, sometimes achieving a lot of success. The songs (points) of intotos for the deities of umbanda are instruments that update the identity of entities through characteristics and components of everyday life and that are articulated with various elements of Brazilian social imaginary ( Nascimento, Souza, & Trindade, 2001Nascimento, A. R. A., Souza, L., Trindade, Z. A. (2001). Exus and Doves-Giras: the masculine and the feminine in the sung points of the umbanda. Psychology in Study, 6(2), 107-113. doi:10.1590/S1413-73722001000200015 ).

The materialities chosen to make up the corpus of analysis were taken from books whose content includes the dissemination of points (chants) of umbanda entities. Four materialities were selected from fragments of songs chanted to the Pomba-Giras. These materialities were taken from the book Points sung by umbanda , written by Marcos Scliar. It should be emphasized that the DA is operationalized as the research corpus was analyzed , seeking its interdiscursivities (when one discourse is crossed by another), as well as the possible effects of meaning that the words provided to the perspective of their production context. The concept of discursive memory was also mobilized by observing that some elements present in the songs already referred to an "already said." The choice of these songs is anchored in the fact that they are the most chanted and common in various terreiros . The first song to be analyzed concerns the arrival of the Pomba-Giras in the turns:

Arreda (get away), man, here comes woman!

Arreda (get away), man, here comes woman!

She's the Pomba-Gira , the queen of the cabaret

Seven men come forward to say who she is

She's the Pomba-Gira , the queen of the cabaret

This song was recorded recently by Mariene de Castro ( Farias, 2020Farias, D. (2020). Exu and Pombagira Points – Mariene de Castro [Video]. Recovered from https://bit.ly/38H1tZx
https://bit.ly/38H1tZx...
). The utterance in this fragment assumes an imperative character ordering the departure of men, as can be seen in the word "arreda" (get away). This utterance emanates several meanings and interpretations, including: (a) the song aims to warn that the Pomba-Gira , a female entity, will arrive; men should be afraid, because a female being will take over the space, whether geographical or spiritual; (b) there is a rivalry between men and women, and both cannot occupy the same space; however, the woman holds more power, since it is she who dominates (she is the "queen of the cabaret"); (c) females and males can inhabit the same space, but with a certain distance; (d) the utterance " arreda man" makes it possible to understand that women will occupy a place that was once occupied by men; women begin to enter in male spaces, not peacefully, but through imposition, thus evidencing the power of women; (e) the authoritarian character of ordering shows that women can have male characteristics, such as aggressiveness, so that they conquer spatialities; that is, a female "body" is also a source of (re)production of masculinities. In the utterance "seven men come forward to say who she is," "come forward" emerges to affirm that the Pomba-Gira also raises an idea of submission of these men’s greatness.

Another possible interpretation is anchored in the idea that the female being assumes a distinct image from that proposed by patriarchal society: the woman submissive to men gives way to one who orders them to make way, because she will pass, while they only enter this space to refer to her (say who she is). Through these analyses, it is possible to verify that the gender causes in this "body" a discontinuity, thus breaking with the biological and with the binarism exposed by Oyěwùmí (2017)Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. . By saying that "seven men come forward to say who she is," the utterance allows us to understand that men are not in charge, since they occupy the role of enunciators, showing the power of the feminine. Another possible reading, which also inferiorizes women, is the fact that men are still always the first, putting the feminine in the background. However, the fact that there are seven men who announce her arrival evidences a transgressive character, considering that they may appear as a possession or even as loving partners. Another effect of meaning allows us to understand that men have the role of heralds: the position of the Pomba-Gira prevents her from speaking to anyone, she only speaks through heralds or emissaries; men come to be understood as mortal, while the feminine remains divinized. Therefore, this utterance converses with the thought of Cruz (2007)Cruz, A. M. L. L. (2007). From queen of the yard to the back of evil: a study on gender and ritual. (Doctoral thesis). Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ. , according to which the Pomba-Gira manifests as a transgression of the images of what is socially considered as feminine, since she is an eloquent deity and often presents both male and female characteristics.

In this sense, the feminine, not the Pomba-Gira , presents itself as a transgression, since it confronts Christian thought, as pointed out by Barros and Bairrão (2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 . The sense effect of being called queen causes an emptying of the power attributed to her, considering that, to be queen, there must be a king. Retrieving the discursive memory, the figure of the king is predominant over that of the queen, thus removing the protagonism of the feminine, which contributes to gender inequality, since there is a pseudodependence of the feminine being. These issues, in part, converse with the thinking of Barros and Bairrão (2015)Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606 , that the Pomba-Gira is often represented as an authoritarian, aggressive, conquering, and active deity. These characteristics, in Brazilian society, are examples of masculinity, therefore belonging to the male universe. This fact exemplifies Olajubu's (2003) thought that women can perform tasks aimed at men and vice versa, also evidencing the thinking of Oyěwùmí (2017)Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. . For the author, the body is only a marker, but not a definer of gender. This song also makes it possible to understand the feminine not as a unit, but as something fragmented, since it does not express a "pure" feminine identity. In the next discourse, it is possible to verify the repetition of the need for the feminine to occupy space, as well as the "body" being presented as a place that manifests both the masculine and the feminine.

Open the wheel

Open the wheel

Let the Pomba-Gira work

She's got a steel chest,

She's got steel chest

And the heart of a thrush

The previous song is known as "The Feast of Maria Padilha" ( Stonlogun Music Group, 2020Stonlogun Music Group. (2021). Festa De Maria Padilha - Doté Severino (Official Song Music) [Video]. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3MPfdjT
https://bit.ly/3MPfdjT...
). The utterance "open the wheel" produces a sense effect that refers to the need for the female to occupy the space so that she can act, even if it is in a delimited space. However, this space can be composed of subjects who perform different genders, since the "wheel" consists of a set of people. Unlike the previous discourse, there is no character of ordering and emptying of space (in the case of men), but rather the need to put the feminine at the center, when opening the wheel for the Pomba-Gira to work. The utterance "She's got a steel breast and the heart of a thrush" suggests a metaphorical effect, allowing other interpretations, as shown by Orlandi (2016)Orlandi, E. P. (2016). Discourse under analysis: subject , sense, ideology. Campinas, SP: Bridges. . Therefore, the figure of the Pomba-Gira appears as a resistant subject with high malleability. The utterance gains this meaning in that the word "iron" could have been chosen instead of "steel," that is, the Pomba-Gira represents a much more resistant feminine being with greater adaptability.

This feminine being, expressed in the figure of the Pomba-Gira , initially presents itself as essential to life, fragile and free, as seen in the utterance "the heart of a thrush." Another possible interpretation is that the heart can be seen through its metaphorical condition as a sign linked to love, considering that the word "heart" takes on different meanings because of interdiscourse. The "heart" of a thrush can refer to a form of free love, without an owner, considering that birds, in the social imaginary, represent freedom or allow an understanding of the free ways to love a welcoming woman. In addition to the above, the statement evidences an intense and fragile feminine being, since the hearts of birds are more accelerated and delicate. It is important to note that any bird could have been chosen, but choosing the thrush raises an ideological issue, common to the discourse, as already pointed out by Pêcheux (1988)Pêcheux, M. (1988). Semantics and discourse: a critique of the statement of the obvious. Campinas, SP: Unicamp. .

The first question is anchored in the fact that the thrush has been consecrated as a bird that represents Brazil, so this character of the Pomba-Gira manifests as a representation of many Brazilian women. Another effect of meaning, which emerges through interdiscourse, lies in the meaning of the word " sabiá " in Tupi: "he who prays a lot", in allusion to the bird's ability to learn various sounds, thus attributing to the Pomba-Gira the characteristics of a wise woman. These characteristics converse with the thoughts of Birman (2005)Birman, P. (2005). Sex and trances: sex and gender in Afro-Brazilian cults, a flyover. Feminist Studies, 13(2), 403-414. Doi:10.1590/S0104-026X2005000200014 , Capone (2004)Capone, S. (2004). Africa's search for candomblé: tradition and power in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Pallas. , and Mesquita and Oliveira (2021), since these authors affirm that the Pomba-Gira breaks with the power relations present in both the affective and social spheres of practitioners of Afro-Brazilian religions, creating a break with the bio-logic exposed by Oyěwùmí (2017)Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera. . The effects of meanings produced by the analyzed utterance create a break with the thoughts of Passos (2021), for whom there is a hegemony of the sex/gender system that can be observed in the myths of deities, for example.

The Pomba-Gira is the wife of seven husbands!

The Pomba-Gira is the wife of seven husbands!

But don't mess with her!

The Pomba-Gira is dangerous!

She's the Pomba-Gira , the crossroads queen,

Who faces her enemies

With a loud laugh.

This fragment was extracted from the point known as "Pomba-Gira is the wife of seven husbands" ( Oliveira, 2008Oliveira, P. (2008). Ponto - Pomba Gira - Wife of 7 husbands [Video]. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3G3gAIZ
https://bit.ly/3G3gAIZ...
). The discourse contained in the fragment has an utterance that presents the Pomba-Gira as a contravening female entity, stating that "she is the wife of seven husbands," because it creates a break with the Western thought of monogamous marriage. The misdemeanor also appears in the fact that in several countries only men are allowed to marry several women, with the opposite being penalized. Another possible interpretation is that, by having more than one husband, the Pomba-Gira shows herself as a source of struggle against male domination, considering that she does not play the role of submissive wife, but as a free woman who can choose several partners. Through this statement, it is perceived that there is no relationship of oppression of women on the part of men, as the Pomba-Gira manifests as a deity that sets the balance between men and women. Therefore, this utterance converses with the thoughts of Olajubu (2003)Olajubu, O. (2003). Women in the Yoruba religious sphere. Albany: State University of New York Press. and Oyěwùmí (2011)Oyěwùmí, O. (2011). Decolonizing the Intellectual and the Quotidian: Yorùbá Scholars(hip) and Male Dominance. In o. Oyěwùmí (Org.) , Gender and epistemologies in Africa: gendering traditions, spaces, social institutions, and identities (pp. 9-33). New York: Palgrave Macmillan. doi:10.1057/9780230116276_2
https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230116276_2...
, for whom the idea of male domination is not present in some Yorùbá societies.

The utterance also generates another sense effect that is not passivity. By presenting female polygamy as a transgression, this figure that represents the feminine as a dangerous subject is capable of having several attitudes that are considered transgressive. The utterance "Who faces her enemies with a strong laugh" allows us to understand that this entity also has a combative character and that it does not let its enemies (male figures) do what they want. It is important that the Pomba-Gira , in the chosen utterance, has no enemies, which gives a sense of union between female subjects. The discourse presented highlights the Pomba-Gira as a representation of the feminine, as the center of the reorganization of power relations that permeate the social and affective spheres. Mesquita and Oliveira (2021) affirm that these deities are important to think about the reorganization of power relations, mainly through how they affect the social life of adherents and members of religious organizations of African origin, as well as through the need to face male domination. The discourses analyzed in this article show the Pomba-Gira as a representation of the feminine who is autonomous, wise, independent, daring, subversive, courageous, free, and able to conquer what she wants, being a power of elaboration of a feminine woman that diverges from what is seen as traditional and that questions gender inequality.

In red and black

Wearing the night, the mystery brings

Gold necklace, gold earrings

The promise makes

If you must go, you can go ask for whatever you want

But beware, friend, she's beautiful, she's a woman

And at the corner of the street turning, spinning, spinning

She's a pretty girl, spinning, spinning, spinning there

Spinning, laroiê spinning there

This utterance is part of a song popularly known as "Moça bonita," recorded by Brazilian folk singers such as Ângela Maria and Rita Ribeiro ( Benneditto, 2019Benneditto, R. (2019). Rita Benneditto - Pretty Girl (Exu Points) [Video]. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3MC6y3X
https://bit.ly/3MC6y3X...
). The fragment has several sequences of utterances. In the first, the Pomba-Gira is described as a mysterious and seductive woman, because, in discursive memory, red is considered to be the color of sensuality and black the color of mystery. The utterance "wearing the night, the mystery brings" makes it possible to understand the Pomba-Gira as a representation of the feminine who is free to walk the streets at any time of the day, but it is the night that the mystery inhabits. By exposing the fact that she wears a gold necklace and gold earrings, this deity is evidenced as a holder of riches, able to make promises, that is, as a woman capable of fulfilling commitments. Thus, the feminine is manifested as a liberating character. Another statement warns the enunciator that he is free to ask for anything, but a warning is given and shows that it is not possible to deceive women. It causes an effect of meaning that refers to female power, according to which the Pomba-Gira brings the identity of the woman who owns her own desires. The analyses derived from the previous utterance converse with the thoughts of both Meyer (1993)Meyer, M. (1993). Maria Padilha and her entire gang: a lover of a king of castela: the Dove-Gira of umbanda. São Paulo, SP: Two Cities. and Kings (2020)Kings, L. (2020). The figure of Pombagira: transgression and female empowerment. Sacrilegens, 17(1), 109-126. doi:10.34019/2237-6151.2020.v17.30810
https://doi.org/10.34019/2237-6151.2020....
, because for the authors the Pomba-Gira is a figure of subversion of what is socially understood as feminine, since she is wise, seductive, erotic, and even a sorceress. Moreover, the Pomba-Gira represents, through the analysis of the previous song, a disruption of female submission, because she brings freedom of sexuality and breaks the rules preestablished by society. In this context, according to Costa (2015)Costa, O. S. (2015). The Dove-Gira: mythical resignification of the goddess Lilith (Doctoral thesis). Pontifical Catholic University of Goiás, Goiânia, GO. , she breaks with the historical continuity of female submission and the idea of the woman as the man's possession.

The notion of freedom is also present in the fragment – "And in the corner of the street turning, spinning, spinning" – because it refers to the notion of freedom of the woman: she can turn down the street regardless of the eyes of others, because she knows how to defend herself from those who mess with her. These questions illustrate Simas's (2019) thinking by evidencing the Pomba-Gira as a potential representation of female power and independent women. In this discursive sequence, an utterance allows an effect of meaning that presupposes that every beautiful woman is innocent and incapable of having attitudes that allow her to defend herself against men, since the warning is given to men ("but careful, friend"). This DS exemplifies Barros's (2013) thought that Pomba-Giras and their incorporations enable a "reupdate" of what is understood as a female figure, continuously offering a plurality of possibilities to understand female experiences.

Through this statement, it is also perceived that the Pomba-Gira makes it possible to understand gender from the experiences of a people, or even based on the divinity itself. In general, it is perceived that the songs chanted for the Pomba-Giras speak of their experiences that also reflect the lives of adherents of Afro-Brazilian religions. As already pointed out by Olajubu (2003)Olajubu, O. (2003). Women in the Yoruba religious sphere. Albany: State University of New York Press. , gender is constituted through the life experiences of a people. These experiences are instilled and manifest at different levels, such as the political, theoretical, and political. Thus, gender is not an independent construction of social systems and cannot be seen as a fixed construct, but as a process.

Closing the Gira

♪The farewell of a rose

Makes you cry, makes you cry, makes you sob♪

In this section, the guiding research question of this article is taken up again: how do religious organizations of African origin, through discourses expressed in songs aimed at Pomba-Giras, challenge gender stereotypes and how do these songs enable the understanding of multiple femininities and masculinities?

It is considered that the Pomba-Gira , as a representation of the feminine, is inserted in an ambiguous situation in the classifications of being a man and being a woman. It presents socially constructed characteristics as belonging to the male universe, contrasting with the cisheteronormativity of outside religious organizations of African origin. Considering that the Pomba-Gira is endorsed with power, this female figure goes in the opposite direction to the normative intelligibility reducer that states that the only way for female subjects to become powerful and independent is if they are bound to or dependent on men. Thus, what would attribute power to the Pomba-Gira would lie in the performance of gender, despite being a female being and, simultaneously, presenting characteristics attributed to men. It can be observed that in one of the recurring themes in the chants sung – the different roles that the feminine figure can play in society – what is known and what is said about women in this afro-religious environment is, often, a mixture of resistance and reproduction of the woman as a passive figure, or as a subversive and transgressive figure.

We consider that discourses cannot be disrelated from the socio-historical conditions of their production. Therefore, the discourses that emerge in religious organizations ( terreiros), through the sung points of umbanda, are sequences of utterances that arise during a religious ritual and seek to revere the deities, in this case the Pomba-Giras , thus creating a status that puts them in a position of worship. Thus, the DFs of umbanda points very clearly clash with the meaning that words assume in popular knowledge about gender, women, and love relationships.

The discourses of the terreiros expressed by the points sung to the Pomba-Giras are positioned to value the freedom of women, this being a type of freedom that manifests in opposition to Christian moralization. The enunciations show the figure of the woman who laughs while facing her enemies, who has seven husbands and conquers male spaces. In this way, they are in favor of gender equality, freedom of expression, and even resistance to a paralyzing moralization.

Finally, we observed that by studying gender in religious organizations, through the figure of the Pomba-Gira , spaces are opened up for new dialogues within the field of organizational studies, besides understanding how some words used in daily life, to belittle and devalue women, can assume other meanings, contributing to the understanding of "feminine doing" in a non-puritanical way. We dare say that the Pomba-Gira is not only a deity, but also one of the numerous forms of gender performance , serving as a lens to understand other forms of resistance and the existence of multiple femininities in various types of organizations and organizational practices. In this sense, following the thoughts of Oyěwùmí (2016)Oyěwùmí, O. (2016). What gender is motherhood? changing Yorùbá ideals of power, procreation, and identity in the age of modernity. New York: Palgrave. by proposing an Oxunista analysis of gender, based on the characteristics of the divinity Ọ̀ṣun ( Oxum ), we suggest pombajirismo here as an analytical orientation for gender studies.

Nevertheless, we should emphasize that although they are inserted in a Western context marked by patriarchal culture, in religious organizations of African origin it is possible to identify a predominance of the female role as a leader, whether in the religious field, or in the organizational structure of the terreiros or houses of Candomblé . Leaderships characterized by the female presence can be widely verified in several studies ( Menezes, 2005Menezes, L. (2005). The Yalorixás of Recife. Recife, PE: Funcultura. ; Moura & Silva, 2020Moura, R. G., & Silva, E.B. (2020, November). Iyámi Agba Wa O: the cult of female deities in religious organizations of African origin and the appreciation of women. Article presented at the XXIII Semead Administration Seminar, the n-line. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3yJllWG
https://bit.ly/3yJllWG...
; Santos, 2008Santos, I.M.F. (2008). Iá Mi Oxorongá: ancestral mothers and female power in the African religion. Sankofa, 1(2), 59-81. doi:10.11606/issn.1983-6023.sank.2008.88730 ), dealing with the importance of female characters for the consolidation and tradition of the terreiros of African religions in Brazil. This fact may reflect the view one has about the female gender, as synonymous with strength, courage, resistance, autonomy, freedom, and leadership, identified in the songs analyzed, in opposition to the view of the female gender present in Western society under the aegis of Christianity. In this sense, we suggest for future studies an analysis of religious organizations from the perspective of leadership, considering gender issues and the valorization of women in institutions embedded in a patriarchal culture.

It is important to point out that even in decolonial or postcolonial works, it is difficult not to resort to authors from the epistemic North to make up and structure both the theoretical and methodological path. Therefore, we leave as a suggestion for future works, articles, or essays the use of a research method based on Afrocentrality, taking ancestral knowledge as a starting point.

Acknowledgements

We thank all the people on the streets for allowing this research to take place. We thank the reviewers for their rich contributions, enabling the improvement of the research carried out.

References

  • Asante, M. K. (2009). Afrocentricity: notes on a disciplinary position. In E. L. Nascimento, Afrocentricity: an innovative epistemological approach (pp. 93-110). São Paulo, SP: Black Seal.
  • Alvesson, M., Billing, Y. D. (2009). Understanding gender and organizations. London: Sage.
  • Astley, W.G. (1985). Administrative science as socially constructed truth. Administrative Science Quarterly, 30(4), 497-513. doi:10.2307/2392694
  • Azeredo, L., Bartho, V. D. (2020). Analysis of the French discourse: Pêcheux and Foucault, two "micheis" in their (dis)meetings. Paths in Applied Linguistics, 23(2), 36-56. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3lkdlmX
    » https://bit.ly/3lkdlmX
  • Baby. M. L. (2013). "The gods will not be scandalized": ancestry and scandalized: ancestry and reminiscences of feminine reminiscences of female subversives in the sacred subversives in the sacred. Feminist Studies, 21(2), 509-534. doi:10.1590/S0104-026X2013000200005
  • Barros, M. L., & Bairrão, J. F.M. H. (2015). Gender performances in umbanda: Pomba-Gira as an Afro-Brazilian interpretation of "woman"? Journal of the Institute of Brazilian Studies, 62(1), 126–145. doi:10.11606
  • Benneditto, R. (2019). Rita Benneditto - Pretty Girl (Exu Points) [Video]. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3MC6y3X
    » https://bit.ly/3MC6y3X
  • Bernardo, T. (2005). Candomblé and female power. Revista Estudos da Religião, 2(1),1-21. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3NqoJd7
    » https://bit.ly/3NqoJd7
  • Birman, P. (2005). Sex and trances: sex and gender in Afro-Brazilian cults, a flyover. Feminist Studies, 13(2), 403-414. Doi:10.1590/S0104-026X2005000200014
  • Bruyne, P., Herman, J., Schoutheete, M. (1977). Dynamics of research in social sciences: the poles of methodological practice. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Francisco Alves.
  • Capone, S. (2004). Africa's search for candomblé: tradition and power in Brazil. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Pallas.
  • Costa, O. S. (2015). The Dove-Gira: mythical resignification of the goddess Lilith (Doctoral thesis). Pontifical Catholic University of Goiás, Goiânia, GO.
  • Cruz, A. M. L. L. (2007). From queen of the yard to the back of evil: a study on gender and ritual. (Doctoral thesis). Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ.
  • Dyck, B. (2014). God on management: The world's largest religions, the "theological turn," and organization and management theory and practice. Research in the Sociology of Organizations, 41(2), 23-62. doi:10.1108/S0733-558X20140000041010
  • Farias, D. (2020). Exu and Pombagira Points – Mariene de Castro [Video]. Recovered from https://bit.ly/38H1tZx
    » https://bit.ly/38H1tZx
  • Grosfoguel, R. (2006). La descolonización de la economía-política y los estudios postcoloniales: transmodernidad, pensamiento fronterizo y colonialidad global. Tabull Rasa, 4(1), 17-48. doi:10.25058/20112742.245
    » https://doi.org/10.25058/20112742.245
  • Grosfoguel, R. (2008). To decolonize the studies of political economy and postcolonial studies: Transmodernity, frontier thinking and global coloniality. Revista Crítica de Ciências Sociais, 80(1), 115-147. doi:10.4000/rccs.697
    » https://doi.org/10.4000/rccs.697
  • Halberstam, J. (2008). Female masculinidad. Barcelona: Editorial Egales.
  • Hansen, L.L. (2002). Rethinking the Industrial Relations Tradition from a Gender Perspective: An Invitation to Integration. Employee Relations, 24(2), 190-210. doi:10.1108/01425450210420910
    » https://doi.org/10.1108/01425450210420910
  • Haroche, C., Pêcheux, M., Henry, P. (2007). The semantics and the Saussurian cut: language, language, speech. In R.L. Barons (Org.), Analysis of the course: notes to a history of the concept of discursive formation (pp. 13-31). São Carlos, SP: Pedro & João Editores.
  • Lauredo, F., Oliveira, T. (2022). Bewildered administration? a systematic review of the decolonial perspective and studies in organizations. Research, Society and Development, 11 (2), 1-15. doi:10.33448/rsd-v11i2.25378
  • Magellan, A. S., Kogawa, J. (2019). Discourse analysis thinkers: an introduction. Jundiaí, SP: Paco Editorial.
  • Meneses, M. P. (2012). Bodies of violence, resistance languages: the complex knowledge sinets in contemporary Mozambique. Critical Journal of Southern Epistemologies, 80, 161-194. doi:10.4000/rccs.701
    » https://doi.org/10.4000/rccs.701
  • Menezes, L. (2005). The Yalorixás of Recife. Recife, PE: Funcultura.
  • Mosque, D.C, & Oliveira, E. A. (2021). Feminilities and transgressions in a body that rotates: a post-structuralist analysis of scientific production about Pombagira. Periodic Journal, 1(14), 34-49. doi:10.9771/peri.v1i14.36523
  • Meyer, M. (1993). Maria Padilha and her entire gang: a lover of a king of castela: the Dove-Gira of umbanda. São Paulo, SP: Two Cities.
  • Moura, R. G., & Silva, E.B. (2020, November). Iyámi Agba Wa O: the cult of female deities in religious organizations of African origin and the appreciation of women. Article presented at the XXIII Semead Administration Seminar, the n-line. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3yJllWG
    » https://bit.ly/3yJllWG
  • Nascimento, A. R. A., Souza, L., Trindade, Z. A. (2001). Exus and Doves-Giras: the masculine and the feminine in the sung points of the umbanda. Psychology in Study, 6(2), 107-113. doi:10.1590/S1413-73722001000200015
  • Olajubu, O. (2003). Women in the Yoruba religious sphere. Albany: State University of New York Press.
  • Oliveira, P. (2008). Ponto - Pomba Gira - Wife of 7 husbands [Video]. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3G3gAIZ
    » https://bit.ly/3G3gAIZ
  • Orlandi, E. P. (2004). Interpretation: authorship , reading and deeds of symbolic work. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Voices.
  • Orlandi, E. P. (2012). Discourse analysis: principles and procedures. Campinas, SP: Bridges.
  • Orlandi, E. P. (2016). Discourse under analysis: subject , sense, ideology. Campinas, SP: Bridges.
  • Oyěwùmí, O. (2004). Conceptualizing gender: the Eurocentric foundations of feminist concepts and the challenge of African epistemologies. CODESRIA Gender Series, 1, 1-8. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3MrA8cl
    » https://bit.ly/3MrA8cl
  • Oyěwùmí, O. (2011). Decolonizing the Intellectual and the Quotidian: Yorùbá Scholars(hip) and Male Dominance. In o. Oyěwùmí (Org.) , Gender and epistemologies in Africa: gendering traditions, spaces, social institutions, and identities (pp. 9-33). New York: Palgrave Macmillan. doi:10.1057/9780230116276_2
    » https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230116276_2
  • Oyěwùmí, O. (2016). What gender is motherhood? changing Yorùbá ideals of power, procreation, and identity in the age of modernity. New York: Palgrave.
  • Oyěwùmí, O. (2017). La invención de las mujeres: una perspectiva africana sobre los discursos occidentales de género. Bogotá: Editorial en la Frontera.
  • Steps, A.C. (2021). When an analytical category enters the xirê: thinking gender from candomblé. Periodics, 14(1), 9-33. Doi:10.9771/peri.v1i14.36666
  • Pelucius, L. (2012). Subaltern who, pale face? Notes on the margins about post-colonialisms, feminisms and queer studies. Contemporary, 2(2), 395-418. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3FVVs7k
    » https://bit.ly/3FVVs7k
  • Pêcheux, M. (1969). Analyse automatique du discours. Paris: Dunod.
  • Pêcheux, M. (1988). Semantics and discourse: a critique of the statement of the obvious. Campinas, SP: Unicamp.
  • Pêcheux, M. (2014). Automatic speech analysis (AAD-69). In F. Gadet, T. Hak (Orgs.) , By an automatic discourse analysis: an introduction to the work of Michel Pêcheux (pp. 74-94). Campinas, SP: Unicamp.
  • Pêcheux, M. (2015). Language, languages, speech. In E.P. Orlandi, Discourse analysis: Michel Pêcheux (pp. 283-294). Campinas, SP: Editors Bridges.
  • Prandi, R. (1996). Axé heiress. Sao Paulo, SP: Hucitec.
  • Kings, L. (2020). The figure of Pombagira: transgression and female empowerment. Sacrilegens, 17(1), 109-126. doi:10.34019/2237-6151.2020.v17.30810
    » https://doi.org/10.34019/2237-6151.2020.v17.30810
  • Santos, I.M.F. (2008). Iá Mi Oxorongá: ancestral mothers and female power in the African religion. Sankofa, 1(2), 59-81. doi:10.11606/issn.1983-6023.sank.2008.88730
  • Saraceni, R. (2014). Doctrine and theology of a sacred band: the religion of mysteries a hymn of love for life. Sao Paulo, SP: Madras.
  • Simas, L.A. (2019). The enchanted body of the streets. Rio de Janeiro, RJ: Brazilian Civilization.
  • Souza, C. (2019). Let the Dove-Gira work! : at the crossroads, paths and gender mispaths. Florianópolis, SC: Fire: Tribe of the Island.
  • Stonlogun Music Group. (2021). Festa De Maria Padilha - Doté Severino (Official Song Music) [Video]. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3MPfdjT
    » https://bit.ly/3MPfdjT
  • Teixeira, J.C., Oliveira, J. S., & Carrieri, A. P. (2020). Why talk about race in Organizational Studies in Brazil? From biological discussion to the political dimension. Revista Perspectivas Contemporâneas, 15(1), p. 46-70. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3wj8GrD
    » https://bit.ly/3wj8GrD
  • Teixeira, J.C., Oliveira, J. S., & Mesquita, J. S. (2019, May). Can intersectionality be Afro-centered in the field of administration? A theoretical essay on the contributions of intersectional theory to the area of administration. Article presented at the National Meeting of Organizational Studies - EnEO, Fortaleza, CE.
  • Tracey, P., Phillips, N. , & Lounsbury, M. (2014). Taking religion seriously in the study of organizations. Research in the Sociology of Organizations, 41(2), 3-21. doi:10.1108/S0733-558X20140000041009
  • Trindade, D. F. (2017). Umbanda manual for beginners. São Paulo, SP: SATTVA Publishing House.
  • Vergara, S.C, & Irigaray, H. A. R. (2000). The orixás of the administration. Public Administration Journal, 34(2), 1-8. Recovered from https://bit.ly/3sKKH2n
    » https://bit.ly/3sKKH2n

Note

  • 1
    . We chose the spelling "Pomba-Gira," with a hyphen, because this is the recurring spelling in the texts on the theme, even being the form used among practitioners of religions of African origins.
  • Plagiarism check
    O&S submits all documents approved for publication to a plagiarism analysis, using a specific tool.
  • Data availability
    O&S encourages data sharing. However, out of respect for ethical dictates, it does not require the disclosure of any means of identification of research participants, fully preserving their privacy. The practice of open data seeks to ensure the transparency of the research results, without revealing the identity of the research participants.
Associate Editor: Josiane Silva Oliveira

Publication Dates

  • Publication in this collection
    15 July 2022
  • Date of issue
    Jul-Sep 2022

History

  • Received
    26 Nov 2021
  • Accepted
    27 Apr 2022
Escola de Administração da Universidade Federal da Bahia Av. Reitor Miguel Calmon, s/n 3o. sala 29, 41110-903 Salvador-BA Brasil, Tel.: (55 71) 3283-7344, Fax.:(55 71) 3283-7667 - Salvador - BA - Brazil
E-mail: revistaoes@ufba.br