TEMA: Epilepsia Rolândica é a forma mais freqüente de epilepsia da infância. Ela é classificada como idiopática, idade-dependente e de evolução benigna. A ausência de comprometimento neuropsicológico faz parte dos critérios de benignidade desta síndrome epiléptica.Entretanto, recentemente têm sido sugeridos vários déficits relacionados à atenção e linguagem. OBJETIVO: o objetivo desse trabalho foi avaliar o desempenho escolar e investigar dificuldades práxicas em pacientes com epilepsia rolândica e comparar a um grupo controle composto por crianças normais com idade, gênero e nível escolar equivalentes. MÉTODO: dezenove pacientes com idade entre 7 e 12 anos foram submetidos a avaliação neurológica clínica, avaliação psicológica, através das Escalas Weschsler de Inteligência e avaliação fonoaudiológica, onde foram avaliados o desempenho escolar e a investigação da presença ou não de dificuldades práxicas. RESULTADOS: os dados mostraram que apesar da eficiência intelectual (medida pelo Quociente Inteligência - QI) estar dentro da média, crianças com epilepsia rolândica mostraram um desempenho significativamente mais pobre do que o grupo controle em provas de escrita, aritmética e leitura. Outro aspecto importante evidenciado foi a ausência de apraxia orofacial nas crianças do grupo afetado. CONCLUSÃO: deve ser ressaltado que a avaliação de crianças com epilepsia é necessária porque isso pode revelar distúrbios específicos que exigem ajuda profissional apropriada. Analisando a ocorrência de distúrbios de linguagem oral e/ou escrita nessas crianças, pode-se evitar um maior prejuízo acadêmico, social e emocional, afinal o prognóstico de uma síndrome epiléptica não depende exclusivamente do controle de crises, pois problemas sociais ou culturais podem interferir tanto quanto as crises na qualidade de vida dos pacientes.
Epilepsia; Linguagem; Criança; Apraxia
BACKGROUND: Rolandic Epilepsy is the most common form of childhood epilepsy. It is classified as idiopathic, age-related epileptic syndrome with benign evolution. The absence of neuropsychological impairment is part of the criteria of benignity of this epilepsy syndrome. Recently, however, several deficits related to attention and language have been suggested. AIM: to assess school performance and to investigate praxis problems in patients with rolandic epilepsy in comparison to a control group of normal children, paired by age, gender and educational level. METHOD: nineteen patients aged between 7 and 12 years underwent clinical neurological evaluation, psychological assessment, through the Weschsler Scales of Intelligence, and language evaluation, to assess the academic performance and to investigate the presence or absence of praxis difficulties. Result: the obtained data indicate that although intellectual efficiency (measured through the Intelligence Quatient - IQ) was within average, children with rolandic epilepsy presented a significantly poorer performance when compared to the control group in tests involving writing, arithmetic and reading. Another important aspect was the absence of orofacial apraxia in children with epilepsy. CONCLUSION: the results of the study suggest that the assessment of children with epilepsy is necessary to investigate specific deficits that require appropriate professional assistance. Regarding the presence of oral language and/or writing disorders in these children, academic, social and emotional deficits can be avoided. The prognosis of epileptic syndrome does not exclusively depend on the control of the crises, since social or cultural problems can interfere in life quality as much as the crisis.
Epilepsy; Language; Children; Praxis
School performance and praxis assessment in children with Rolandic Epilepsy*
Ecila Paula dos Mesquita de OliveiraI,**; Marina Liberalesso NeriII; Lívia Lucena de MedeirosIII; Catarina Abraão GuimarãesIV; Marilisa Mantovani GuerreiroV
IFonoaudióloga. Doutoranda pelo Departamento de Neurologia da Faculdade de Ciências Mêdicas (FCM) da Universidade Estadual de Campinas (Unicamp)
IIPsicóloga. Doutoranda pelo Departamento de Neurologia da FCM da Unicamp
IIIMédica. Pós-Graduanda pelo Departamento de Neurologia da FCM da Unicamp
IVPsicóloga. Pós-Doutoranda pelo Departamento de Neurologia da FCM da Unicamp
VMédica. Doutora e Livre-Docente pela Unicamp. Professora Titular do Departamento de Neurologia da FCM - Unicamp
BACKGROUND: Rolandic Epilepsy is the most common form of childhood epilepsy. It is classified as idiopathic, age-related epileptic syndrome with benign evolution. The absence of neuropsychological impairment is part of the criteria of benignity of this epilepsy syndrome. Recently, however, several deficits related to attention and language have been suggested.
AIM: to assess school performance and to investigate praxis problems in patients with rolandic epilepsy in comparison to a control group of normal children, paired by age, gender and educational level.
METHOD: nineteen patients aged between 7 and 12 years underwent clinical neurological evaluation, psychological assessment, through the Weschsler Scales of Intelligence, and language evaluation, to assess the academic performance and to investigate the presence or absence of praxis difficulties. Result: the obtained data indicate that although intellectual efficiency (measured through the Intelligence Quatient - IQ) was within average, children with rolandic epilepsy presented a significantly poorer performance when compared to the control group in tests involving writing, arithmetic and reading. Another important aspect was the absence of orofacial apraxia in children with epilepsy.
CONCLUSION: the results of the study suggest that the assessment of children with epilepsy is necessary to investigate specific deficits that require appropriate professional assistance. Regarding the presence of oral language and/or writing disorders in these children, academic, social and emotional deficits can be avoided. The prognosis of epileptic syndrome does not exclusively depend on the control of the crises, since social or cultural problems can interfere in life quality as much as the crisis.
Key Words: Epilepsy; Language; Children; Praxis.
Many researchers have studied changes in the development of oral and written language in children with epilepsy. Epilepsy is defined not as a specific disease or single syndrome, but as a group of diseases that have as a common characteristic recurrent epileptic seizures in the absence of toxic-metabolic disorders or fever1.
The excessive and abnormal synchronous electric discharges of nerve cells which cause epileptic seizures interfere in cognitive functions, behavior, consciousness and/or movement.2
Benign childhood epilepsies with centrotemporal rolandic paroxysmal discharges, which are the focus of this study, are classified as a partial epileptic syndrome (temporary dysfunction of a group of neurons in part of the brain) and idiopathic (a genetic predisposition without associated structural modification). Idiopathic partial epilepsies are very common in childhood, corresponding to 25% of all forms of epilepsy. They generally affect children between the ages of 3 and 13.
Because epileptic discharges in rolandic epilepsy involve the perisylvian region, the areas most likely to be affected are language and oral praxias3. This form of epilepsy generally has a benign course, with complete remission and no risk of neuropsychic sequelae, intellectual capacity being preserved. However, recent studies have shown that children may present some specific language-related problems that interfere with learning and/or alterations in oral praxis 4.
The present study seeks to evaluate school performance and investigate praxis related difficulties in patients with benign rolandic epilepsy and compare it to a control group comprised of normal children of matching age, gender and schooling.
The present study was submitted and approved by the UNICAMP Committee for Ethics in Research under the protocol 815/2007.
Nineteen patients with benign rolandic epilepsy age 7 to 12 were studied. They were all treated in the outpatient clinics for Childhood Epilepsy and Neuropsicolinguistics of the Department of Neurology at the UNICAMP Hospital.
The diagnosis of benign rolandic epilepsy was made on the basis of clinical examination and the electroencephalogram. Neuroimaging was performed to rule out brain lesions. All patients had normal neurological, ophthalmological and hearing exams and an intelligence quotient (IQ) equal to or above 80. Parents and/or legal guardians signed informed consent forms authorizing their child's or children's participation in the study.
The following patients were excluded from the study:
1. Those with speech and writing impairments as a result of the following (considering the criteria in the DSM-IV5): pervasive developmental disorders; cerebral palsy; acquired childhood aphasia; hearing impairments (including mild conductive hearing loss); and progressive diseases.
2. Those who did not sign the informed consent form.
The control group consisted of children without neurological diseases matched for sex, age and socio-educational level. The following were excluded from the group: relatives of children with benign rolandic epilepsy, children who had an IQ lower than 80, children on medications that act on the central nervous system, children who were not regularly attending school, children who had a history of neurological problems (such as meningitis, febrile seizures, head trauma with loss of consciousness), children with alterations in the MRI and children with altered neurological exams. Thus the control group was comprised of normal children from similar socio-cultural background to the patients whose parents accepted their inclusion in the study and who signed the informed consent form.
Clinical neurological assessment
The protocol from the Childhood Neurology course at the Department of Neurology at UNICAMP was used for the clinical neurological examination.
The WECHSLER: WPPSI - WISC-III- WECHSLER Intelligence Scale for Children - 3rd edition for children over six6 was used to measure IQ.
. History: interviews with parents or legal guardians were conducted to find out about: delays and/or alterations in language development; gestational history; conditions at birth; family history of speech delay; speech development and hearing; general cognitive development; development of learning skills; motor development; physical development; development of the estomatognathic system and social and environmental conditions;
. Speech test: the children who participated in the study were tested using specific tests to measure: praxis, reading and writing.
. Tests to examine phonoarticulatory organs for anatomical and/or functional alterations that could compromise the child's speech. Bucco-facial and articulatory praxis were tested using the Hage protocol7;
. EAT - Educational Achievement Test8 to assess school performance and its compatibility with chronological age in literate children.
The data collected was described and compared using the Chi-squared test, with the purpose of verifying possible differences between the groups. A significance level of 5% (0.050) was used for the statistical test. SPSS (Statistical Package for Social Sciences) version 17.0 was used to obtain the results.
Table 1 describes the results of the praxis tests for both the study and the control group. There was no statistically significant difference between the groups.
Table 2 describes the general results from the Educational Achievement Test (EAT) for the study group and the control group. The statistical analysis showed a significant difference between the groups.
Given the study's objective of assessing school performance and praxis related abilities in patients with benign rolandic epilepsy and comparing it to a control group of normal children matched for age, sex and schooling, some relevant aspects will be now highlighted.
Orofacial or bucofacial apraxia, according to Ortiz9, is characterized by difficulty in performing isolated or sequential orofacial movements. The presence of dispraxia or orofacial apraxia in children with benign rolandic epilepsy seems to indicate a dysfunction of cerebral regions involved in the planning and execution of non-linguistic complex movements, that is, the lower rolandic motor region10. Due to the location of the epileptic discharges in the centrotemporal regions, specific interferences with language and oral motor functions may occur.
There was no statistically significant difference between the groups. This can be explained by the fact that none of the children who participated in the study were taking medication and/or were being clinically controlled with antiepileptic drugs.
In regard to schooling, however, our findings show a statistically significant difference between the two groups that is consistent with most of the studies that investigate learning disabilities in children related to language3,11 attention and memory,11 speech awareness12 and school performance13, 14.
It is known that the frequency of epilepsy is high at school age14 and many affected children end up not doing well in school.15.
Piccirilli et al's studies 16 suggest that children with benign rolandic epilepsy are at risk for learning difficulties. These findings also support the idea that focal paroxysm, although unrelated to an organic lesion, can interrupt cognitive function in a developing brain. This statement is consistent with studies17 which attributed learning disabilities in children with epilepsy to psychosocial consequences of epilepsy or which classified them as side-effects of the antiepileptic medications administered to patients. Aldenkamp 18 estimates that approximately 30% of children have learning disorders.
The specific results of the EAT subtests - writing, arithmetic and reading - also supported the statistical difference in the test's global result. In the three subtests there was a significant statistical difference between the group of children with epilepsy and the control group, reinforcing the notion that reading and writing disorders are the most expected co-morbidities of benign rolandic epilepsy since the clinical findings and EEG results are a reflection of a disorder in the perisylvian region.
According to recent studies those learning skills most affected in children with benign rolandic epilepsy, such as reading, writing and spelling, are also characteristic of dyslexia, which is the most common disturbance found in classrooms.
In 198619 Dodrill stated that the early onset of epileptic seizures would have a determining role in compromising some mental abilities and would consequently affect school performance. This was indeed observed in the group we studied. The children who had their first seizure at an early age had worse performances when compared to those with later onset seizures.
The study of the relationship between epilepsy and cognitive dysfunction presents some methodological problems. In epileptic patients, countless factors can affect neuropsychological performance: age at onset of seizures, duration of the disorder, type, frequency, seriousness and the total number of seizures, damage to the subjacent brain structure and etiology, location of the electroencephalographic focus, and duration of treatment. 20. It is important to emphasize this since these results are part of a doctoral thesis that should be concluded in the first semester of 2011. All the factors cited above as capable of affecting the results were taken into consideration in this study and will continue to be considered in the thesis.
Few studies have examined the prevalence of speech and writing disorders in children with epilepsy. Such problems are frequently ignored. Caution is necessary in the interpretation of results of this study due to the small number of children included. However, our findings are consistent with the majority of other studies which show that children with benign rolandic epilepsy have difficulty with reading and writing, which in turn affects their school performance.
Children diagnosed with benign rolandic epilepsy need to be screened for reading and speech impairments since those can have serious consequences reparable through intervention. Knowing that the average age for benign rolandic epilepsy is seven, and that the age in which reading skills are generally acquired is around five or six, children with benign rolandic epilepsy should be closely observed for difficulties in learning during this time.
Patients with benign rolandic epilepsy would benefit from a professional assessment conducted by a psychologist and a speech therapist at time of diagnosis.
- 1. Commission on Classification and Terminology of the International League against Epilepsy. Proposal for revised classification of epilepsies and epileptic syndromes. Epilepsia. 1989;30:389-99.
- 2. Guerreiro MM, Andermann E, Guerrini R, Dobyns WB, Kuzniecky R, Silver K, Van Bogaert P, Gillain C, David P, Ambrosetto G, Rosati A, Bartolomei F, Parmeggiani A, Paetau R, Salonen O, Ignatius J, Borgatti R, Zucca C, Bastos AC, Palmini A, Fernandes W, Montenegro MA, Cendes F, Andermann F. Familial perisylvian polymicrogyria: a new familial syndrome of cortical maldevelopment. Ann Neurol. 2000;48:39-48.
- 3. Staden U, Isaaca E, Boyd SG, Brandl U, Neville BGR. Language dysfunction in children with rolandic epilepsy. Neuropediatrics. 1988;29:242-8.
- 4. Northcott E, Connoley AM, Berroya A, Sabaz M, McIntyre J, Christie J, et al. The neuropsychological and language of children with benign rolandic epilepsy. J Child Neurology. 2005;46:924-30.
- 5. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of mental disorders. 4 ed. (DSM-IV), Washington: APA; 1994.
- 6. Wechsler D. WISCIII: Wechsler intelligence scale for children-manual. 3th ed., 1991. Adaptação e padronização de uma amostra brasileira. 1Ş ed., Figueiredo, VLM. São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo; 2002.
- 7. Hage SRV. A avaliação fonoaudiológica em crianças sem oralidade. Tópicos em Fonoaudiologia. Rio de Janeiro: Revinter. 2003;5:175-85.
- 8. Stein LM. TDE - Teste de Desempenho Escolar. São Paulo: Casa do Psicólogo; 1994.
- 9. Ortiz KZ. Alterações da fala: Disartrias e Dispraxias. In: Léslie Piccolotto Ferreira; Debora M. Befi-Lopes; Suelly Cecília Olivan Limongi. (Org.). Tratado de Fonoaudiologia. 1 ed. São Paulo: Roca. 2004;1:304-14.
- 10. Deonna TW, Roulet E, Fontan D, Marooz JP. Speech and oromotor deficits of epileptic origin in benign partial epilepsy of childhood with rolandic spikes (BPERS). Relationship to the acquired aphasia-epilepsy syndrome. Neuropediatrics. 1993;24:83-7.
- 11. Massa R, Saint-Martin A, Carcangiu R, Rudolf G, Seegmuller C, Kleitz C, Metz-Luztz M, Hirsch E, Marescaux C. EEG criteria predictive of complicated evaluation in idiopatic rolandic epilepsy. Neurology. 2001;57:1071-9.
- 12. Miziara CSMG. Avaliação das funções cognitivas na Epilepsia focal benigna da infância com descargas centrotemporais. [Tese]. São Paulo(SP). Universidade de São Paulo. 2003.
- 13. Fonseca LC, Tedrus GMAS, Tonelotto JMF, Antunes TA, Chiodi MG. Desempenho Escolar em Crianças com Epilepsia benigna da infância com pontas centrotemporais. Arq neuropsiquiatr. 2004;62:459-62.
- 14. Hirtz DG, Nelson KB. Cognitive effects of antiepileptic drugs. In: Pedley TA, Meldrum BS eds. Recent advances in epilepsy. New York: Churchill-Livingstone. 1985:161-81.
- 15. Myklebust H. Educational problems of children with epilepsy in comission for the control of epilepsy and its consequences. Plan for Nationwide Action on Epilepsy. 1977;2(1):474-90.
- 16. Piccirilli M, D'Alessandro P, Tiacci C, Ferroni A. Language lateralization in children with benign partial epilepsy. Epilepsia. 1988;29:19-25.
- 17. Beaussart M, Faou R. Evolution of epilepsy with rolandic paroxysmal foci: a study of 324 cases. Epilepsia. 1978;19: 337-42.
- 18. Aldenkamp AP, Alpherts WCJ, Dekker MJA, Overweg J. Neuropsychological aspects of learning disabilities in epilepsy. Epilepsia. 1990;31(4):9-20.
- 19. Dodrill CB. Correlates of generalized tonic-clonic seizures with intellectual neuropsychological, emotional and function in patients with epilepsy. Epilepsia. 1986;27: 399-411.
- 20. O' Leary DS, Seidenberg M, Berent S, Boll TJ. Effects of age onset of tonic seizureson neuropsychological performance in children. Epilepsia. 1981;22:197-204.
Publication in this collection
16 Nov 2010
Date of issue
03 Aug 2010
19 Jan 2010
01 Sept 2010